Is Solar Worth It?
"Is solar worth it?" has no universal answer, and any source that gives you one without asking about your roof, your prices and your usage is selling something. What exists is a short list of questions whose answers decide it — and all of them are knowable before you sign anything.
This guide works through those questions in order, with the two Dwellario solar calculators doing the arithmetic at each step.
Whether solar is worth it is a question with four parts, and this guide asks them in order: what will the roof generate, how much of that will you use yourself, what does the system cost after incentives, and what payback do those three answers imply. Answering them in that order matters, because each answer changes the next one: a system that generates a lot but exports most of it at a low export rate is worth less than a smaller system whose output is mostly used at home.
The two calculators on this site split the question in the same way. The Solar Savings Calculator answers the first two parts: generation and self-consumption, valued at your import and export rates. The Solar Payback Calculator answers the last two: the net cost after incentives, divided by the first-year saving. This guide joins the two calculators together in one worked scenario, so you can see how the saving from the first becomes the payback in the second.
The calculators linked at the end of this guide are the tools for the method in this guide: Solar Savings Calculator, Solar Payback Calculator. Use them first with the numbers from the worked scenario above, and then again with your own numbers, and keep both answers. The first run checks that you have understood the method, because it should reproduce the scenario; the second run gives you the answer for your own home, and it is the one to act on. If the two runs disagree by more than you expect, the difference is in an input, and the field help text on the calculator will tell you which one to check first.
Question 1: what will your roof actually generate?
Everything scales from annual generation in kWh. Get it from installer quotes (insist on the estimate in writing, with the assumptions) or a recognised solar-estimation tool for your address. Orientation, pitch, shading and climate swing the answer enormously for the same panel count — this is why Dwellario never ships an invented "average yield" as a default.
Question 2: how much of it will you use?
Self-used electricity is worth your full import price; exported electricity earns the export tariff, usually far less. A household out all day might self-use 30% of generation; a home worker, or a home with an EV charged at midday, far more. Run the Solar Savings Calculator at a pessimistic and an optimistic self-use share and look at the spread — that spread is your real uncertainty.
Question 3: what does it cost, after incentives, where you live?
Installed prices and incentives are local facts: tax credits, grants, state schemes and VAT treatment all vary by country and year, and installers' quotes for identical hardware vary too. Three quotes is the standard advice for a reason. Only count incentives you have confirmed you qualify for.
Question 4: what payback do those answers imply?
Payback = net installed cost ÷ first-year saving. The Solar Payback Calculator adds a 25-year cumulative table and lets you test your own assumption about future electricity prices — including 0% rise, the conservative case. Also ask what the table leaves out: inverter replacement during the system's life, panel degradation (field studies put the median at around 0.5% a year — see Sources), and maintenance.
The honest bottom line
Solar tends to pencil out best where import prices are high, roofs are unshaded and reasonably oriented, daytime usage is substantial, and incentives are real. It struggles where the opposite holds. The calculators cannot make the decision for you — but with your own four numbers in them, the decision stops being a guess.
A worked scenario, step by step
Start with the Solar Savings Calculator example on this site: a system that generates 4,000 kWh in a year, with 60 percent used at home, an import rate of 0.1819 per kWh and an export rate of 0.05 per kWh. The self-used part is 4,000 times 60 percent, which is 2,400 kWh, and it is worth 2,400 times 0.1819, which is 436.56. The exported part is 4,000 minus 2,400, which is 1,600 kWh, and it is worth 1,600 times 0.05, which is 80.00. The total saving in the first year is 436.56 plus 80.00, which is 516.56.
Now carry that saving into the Solar Payback Calculator. Suppose the system in that example cost 10,000 to install, with 2,000 of incentives, so the net cost is 10,000 minus 2,000, which is 8,000. The simple payback is the net cost divided by the first-year saving: 8,000 divided by 516.56 is 15.49, or about 15.5 years. That is much longer than the 8.0 years in the payback calculator worked example, where the first-year saving was 1,000, and the difference is entirely the saving: 1,000 a year pays back 8,000 in 8 years, while 516.56 a year takes about 15.5 years. The saving is the lever, and the worked examples on the two calculators show it from both ends.
Over 25 years at a flat 516.56 a year, the saving is 516.56 times 25, which is 12,914.00. Against a net cost of 8,000, that leaves 12,914.00 minus 8,000, which is 4,914.00 ahead. Those figures assume the saving stays flat, which it will not: generation falls slowly, the panels degrade by about 0.5 percent a year, and the inverter will usually need replacing around year 10 to 15, as the assumptions on the payback page say. The scenario is a starting point for the decision, not a promise, and it should be re-run with your own generation, your own self-consumption and your own rates.
Common traps
Solar decisions go wrong in a few predictable ways, and each of them is a confusion between two numbers that sound alike:
- Confusing generation with saving. A system that generates 4,000 kWh a year does not save 4,000 kWh worth of import: the part you export is paid at the export rate, which is lower, and the saving is the sum of the two parts valued at their own rates.
- Assuming all of the generation is used at home. Without a battery, self-consumption is often 30 to 50 percent, and the rest is exported. The saving falls sharply as self-consumption falls, because exported energy is worth less.
- Forgetting the inverter. The panels last for decades, but the inverter usually needs replacing around year 10 to 15, and that cost belongs in the decision even though the simple payback calculation leaves it out.
- Using the gross cost instead of the net cost. Incentives reduce the cost that has to be paid back, and the payback should be calculated on the net cost, after incentives, not on the installed cost.
Decision checklist
Work through this list before you sign anything, and re-run both calculators with the numbers you find:
- Get a generation estimate for your own roof, not for an average roof, and write down the kilowatt-hours per year.
- Estimate your self-consumption honestly, and remember that 30 to 50 percent without a battery is the range this site gives.
- Value the self-used part at your import rate and the exported part at your export rate, and add the two.
- Subtract the incentives from the installed cost to get the net cost, and divide it by the first-year saving for the simple payback.
- Ask what changes the answer most: generation, self-consumption or the net cost, and check that number first.
What the saving looks like after ten years
A first-year saving is only the first year, and the panels degrade slowly, by about 0.5 percent a year according to the assumptions on the solar pages. That sounds small, and in one year it is small, but over ten years it is about 5 percent, because 0.5 times 10 is 5. A system that generated 4,000 kWh in its first year would generate about 4,000 times 95 percent, which is 3,800 kWh, in its tenth year, if the fall were exactly 0.5 percent a year. The saving falls with the generation, and the payback calculated on the first-year saving is therefore the best case, not the average case.
The inverter is the other long-term figure to keep in mind. The assumptions on the payback page say it usually needs replacing around year 10 to 15, and that cost belongs in the decision even though the simple payback leaves it out. A payback of 8.0 years on a first-year saving of 1,000, against a net cost of 8,000, is a good result, but it is a result that assumes the system keeps saving at its first-year rate until the cost is recovered, and the degradation and the inverter are the two reasons it will not quite do that. Neither of them overturns a good payback, but both of them shorten the margin, and the honest way to present a payback is with that margin stated.
The decision, then, is not whether the first-year saving is large, but whether the saving over the life of the system, after degradation and after the inverter, is large enough to repay the net cost with a margin you are comfortable with. Run the savings calculator with your own generation and self-consumption, carry the result into the payback calculator, and then ask what happens if the generation is 5 percent lower in year ten and if an inverter replacement falls inside the payback period. If the answer is still yes, the decision is a robust one; if the answer depends on everything going perfectly, it is not.
Try it with your own numbers
Sources
- Framework: standard payback method as used by consumer energy advice services (e.g. Energy Saving Trust, UK; U.S. DOE Energy Saver solar guidance). Accessed November 2026.
- Degradation: NREL review of 2,000+ reported field degradation rates (Jordan & Kurtz) — median 0.5%/year, mean 0.8%/year. A manufacturer performance warranty is a separate guarantee, commonly at least 80% of rated output after 25 years; it is not a measured degradation rate.